Jump to content

Jack Ryan

Proudly Flying The Flag of Chile at a Kingdom Hall - Tell me about JW Neutrality again please?

Recommended Posts

Kingdom Hall in Chile with waving flag, September 2016.

Las Industrias - Santiago

Reuniones semanales
Pasaje Ontario 6332
La Granja
SANTIAGO (Met.)
Coordenadas GPS: -33,514412 -70,614535"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On 11/6/2017 at 8:38 AM, The Librarian said:

There is a reason the society allows it.

I see also that the society allows different internet pages, facebooks, and “closed” facebooks to operate. Something that was not done some years ago. Seems there is a need for that.

 



…. To All those “internet experts”, please Do not forget that, it was a Librarian that started collected news in English (and other languages too) some years ago. Thank you.
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ah, the Atheist returns. I was still waiting on your response concerning Adam and Eve, and your belittling of the religion of Islam with falsehood and misconceptions you proposed on both topics.

That being said, this has been debunked several times. A simple search is only required.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Space Merchant said:

That being said, this has been debunked several times. A simple search is only required.

I can't remember it being debunked. I though we had researched it and found the photograph was genuine. Someone also inquired of the brothers who were familiar with the situation in Chile and they confirmed it...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Anna said:

I can't remember it being debunked. I though we had researched it and found the photograph was genuine. Someone also inquired of the brothers who were familiar with the situation in Chile and they confirmed it...

There were several posts a while back with misinformation of the whole ordeal, it only took one Chilean source to profess what was the cause and effect of the situation in Chile.

That being said, you'd be surprised of how people spread misinformation without even looking into facts, and ignore the situation because they see a flag there without going upon understanding why. So, it was debunked with credible and factual information vs. the misinformation presented out there with a  single source, as is with evidence found by others.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Anna said:

So what exactly was debunked?

The claims of nationalism and idolatry worship due to the fact the flag was there, as is with claims of hypocrisy when it comes to neutrality, which stirred up some misinformation about this whole flag situation. JWinsider provided some information on this in the past, as is with The Librarian, but I can no longer find that topic for it no longer exists. I myself pointed out to Chilean Decree and the like.

The source I professed is below:

    Hello guest!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 6/23/2020 at 4:22 PM, Space Merchant said:

Surely, by now, others have come into contact with brothers from Chile and have been able to confirm or deny what I was told about it. I spoke with a brother who had been there, and had relatives there. I also made lot of phone calls to various congregations (and got no response). I believe the photos are genuine. I believe that the letter content is genuine, although it still bothers me that the words SERVICE DEPARTMENT are in English. I have not been able to find another example of a letter like this. The English contents of the letter are evidently copied exactly from directives on the topic written by brothers at NY HQ. There is absolutely nothing here inconsistent with what Bethel HQ would say about the topic. The inconsistent application of governmental requirements in Chile was also explained to me in a way that makes sense (even if I personally disagree with it).

But I agree with the contents of the letter itself. And I think you are right, SM, that conforming to the governmental requirements about the use of a Chilean flag does not reflect idolatry by the Witnesses there. I doubt they even think about it as anything more than an annoyance to have to put up a national flag now and then. No one is idolizing it. No one is saluting it. In the United States, Witnesses often stand for a flag salute, and just refrain from putting their hand over their heart and repeating some words that people quote mindlessly. The idol itself is meaningless. To me it's a far cry from even "a pinch of incense" at an idol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@JW Insider Yes, unfortunately those who say otherwise do not see this. They will continue to state misinformation, and will do so to those who do not know such things, often times, they do so to belittle them until they meet the next person who corrects them, or the onlooker who knows the truth in all this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Similar Content

    • By Isabella
      La Corte de Apelaciones de Santiago acogió un recurso de protección presentado por el Hospital San José en favor de uno de sus pacientes, para así poder realizarle una transfusión de sangre. Lo cuenta Felipe Delgado en Bío Bío Chile.
      Se trata de un hombre que forma parte de los testigos de Jehová y que está internado en la Unidad de Medicina del centro asistencial, con diagnóstico de anemia severa secundaria a hemorragia digestiva alta de origen variceal, lo que lo mantiene en serio riesgo vital. El paciente, debido a sus creencias, se ha negado a someterse a una transfusión de sangre que resulta vital para salvar su vida.
      En fallo unánime de la primera sala del tribunal de alzada, se acogió la petición esgrimiendo que “ninguna religión, ideología o dogma puede considerarse legítimo si se contrapone con el derecho a la vida ya que en términos de jerarquización existen derechos que priman sobre otros. En otras palabras el derecho a la libertad de conciencia previsto en el artículo 19 N° 6 de la Constitución Política de la República, en cuanto a las creencias religiosas, se encuentra limitada por los derechos fundamentales de los demás y por el derecho a la vida del propio recurrido”.
      Leer más: 
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • Guest Indiana
      By Guest Indiana
      Según autoridades policiales, víctimas de entre 2 y 7 años habrían sufrido abusos en reiteradas ocasiones
      VALPARAÍSO.- Tras la declaración de algunas víctimas, hoy mayores de edad, carabineros del OS-9 de Valparaíso, detuvieron al presunto autor de los delitos sexuales cometidos de forma reiterada y prolongada a menores de entre dos y siete años.
      Así lo afirmó el teniente Arturo Alvarado del OS-9 de Valparaíso, quien señaló que el detenido “era líder en una congregación religiosa y aprovechaba la confianza depositada por sus feligreses para hacer actividades en su domicilio”.
       
       
    • Guest
    • By Jack Ryan
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.  
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content. x

    • By El Bibliotecario
      Crédito fotografía:  Jorge Molina Herrera
      La asamblea regional anual de los Testigos de Jehová tendrá lugar en la ciudad de Coquimbo los días 26, 27 y 28 de octubre en el estadio mundialista Francisco Sánchez Rumoroso. La actividad se enmarca como parte de una serie de asambleas que se realizan todos los años alrededor del mundo en los más de 200 países donde hay Testigos de Jehová. Como en años anteriores, los Testigos están participando en una campaña para invitar personalmente a toda la ciudadanía a este evento. El año pasado, la asistencia total sumada de los tres días superó las 15 mil personas, quienes llegaron procedentes de toda la región para disfrutar de valiosa instrucción bíblica. 15 mil personas asistieron a esta misma instancia durante el 2017. El programa se ha dividido en 54 partes y se presentará en varios formatos, incluidos discursos, entrevistas, audiodramas  y videos cortos. Además, el domingo por la tarde, se mostrará una película titulada "La historia de Jonás, una lección de valentía y compasión". Las sesiones de la mañana y la tarde empezarán todos los días con videos musicales preparados para esta asamblea. Jorge Araya, portavoz de los testigos de Jehová para la región mencionó que: "Hacer frente a las preocupaciones y presiones de la vida es sumamente difícil. Sin importar la edad que tengamos,  necesitamos valor para enfrentarlas con éxito. Precisamente, nuestra asamblea destacará cómo los buenos consejos de la Biblia pueden ayudarnos". "Precisamente, nuestra asamblea destacará cómo los buenos consejos de la Biblia pueden ayudarnos", Jorge Araya, portavoz de los testigos de Jehová para la región. Finalmente Jorge Araya  reiteró la invitación a toda la comunidad: "El programa comenzará cada día a las 9:20 am. Estamos seguros de que todos los que asistan disfrutarán la asamblea. La entrada es gratuita y no se hacen colectas", puntualizó.

      Fuente: Diario el Día - 
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By ARchiv@L
      2016 December Chile Special Convention of JW
       
       
      2016______________________

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.  
       
       
       
       
    • Guest Nicole
      By Guest Nicole
      Una hematoma periventricular y una anemia severa mantienen internada a María José Pinto de 33 años en el Hospital San José en Santiago, a la espera de la solución definitiva de un conflicto que podría ser determinante para su condición médica y que abre una discusión país sobre la existencia de un sistema de salud paternalista versus otro que privilegia la autodeterminación de las personas.
      Según informó el matutino LUN, el recinto asistencial interpuso un recurso de protección a favor de la paciente ante la Corte de Apelaciones de Santiago, con el fin de protegerla de la firme decisión de su familia y de una de sus hermanas, Valeska Pinto, quienes se oponen a que sea sometida a una trasfusión de sangre, ya que todos son Testigos de Jehová, religión que se niega a este tipo de intervenciones.
      Pese a los alegatos de la familia, el tribunal falló a favor del requerimiento hecho por el hospital el pasado 13 de julio, permitiendo al recinto disponer de los tratamientos médicos necesarios para salvaguardar la vida de la mujer.
      http://www.chvnoticias.cl/nacional/acogen-recurso-de-proteccion-presentado-por-hospital-san-jose-para/2018-07-19/180917.html
    • By HollyW
      Are Kingdom Halls in Chile being allowed to display the Chilean flag on September 18th in order to avoid a fine?
    • By ARchiv@L
      In 1943, the Court Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content. when it punished students who were Jehovah’s Witnesses when wouldn’t salute the flag and ...
       
      Student Sues College Over 'Social Justice' Activism Mandate

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
      Jan 22, 2017 @ 07:00 AM ===============

      The Persecution of West Virginia Jehovah's Witnesses 

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
         




×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Service Confirmation Terms of Use Privacy Policy Guidelines We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.