Jump to content

Jack Ryan

Bombay High Court tells woman not to expose her autistic son to any faith other than Zoroastrianism | She is now suspected to be a follower or adherent of Jehovah’s Witnesses.

Topic Summary


Last Reply



Jack Ryan -
Jack Ryan -

Top Posters

Recommended Posts

Bombay HC tells woman not to expose her autistic son to any faith other than Zoroastrianism

The father’s lawyer alleged that the mother and a close relative had taken the son to someplace in Virginia where he was apparently exposed to another religion.

Written by Sailee Dhayalkar | Mumbai | Published: July 30, 2018

The mother has accepted the condition and has given an undertaking to this effect to the court. (Express photo)

The Bombay High Court recently told a mother to not expose her child, who is suffering from autism, to any other religious faith or teachings than Zoroastrianism while they are on a holiday in the US.

The court was hearing an application by the boy’s father objecting to his son traveling abroad with his mother. The mother had moved an application earlier to take her son abroad on a six week holiday to the US. The court was told that the son has been diagnosed with autism. The mother informed the court that they would leave on July 31, from Mumbai for Washington DC and would be back by September 19.

The mother informed the court that while in America, she plans to take her son on a trip to various places including Virginia Beach, Ocean City, Luray Caverns, the Blue Ridge Mountains, New York City, Niagara Falls, Washington DC itself and, if possible on a short cruise.

However, her estranged husband objected to the application. The father’s lawyer told the court that the son should not be sent on this trip because during the last visit in December 2017 through January 2018 there was allegedly some untoward events, which were narrated by the son to his father.

Justice G S Patel held, “One recurrent complaint throughout this matter has been that the defendant (mother) has chosen virtually to abandon the Zoroastrian faith and has turned to an alternative religion. She is now suspected to be a follower or adherent of Jehovah’s Witnesses.”

The father’s lawyer alleged that the mother and a close relative had taken the son to someplace in Virginia where he was apparently exposed to another religion. The lawyer further said that this has been narrated by the son himself to his father.

Justice Patel said, “I am making two things clear to the defendant (mother) so far as ….(son) is concerned. Given his medical condition, should he ever report any such incident, I will accept it as truth. I, therefore, expect that the defendant must put aside during the time of this visit and whenever…(son) is in her care, all considerations of another religion and she must not and will not at any stage and in any manner, however tangential, expose… (son) to any other faith or teachings.”

The mother has accepted the condition and has given an undertaking to this effect to the court.

Justice Patel warned the mother, “I am making it plain that should I find the slightest breach of this condition, I will make an order against the defendant restricting or even taking away all access that she may have to…(son). I cannot stress this enough. This question of faith is an extremely sensitive matter and…(son) has to be shielded from any conflict or trauma at any cost.”


The Indian Express is an English-language Indian daily newspaper. It is published in Mumbai by Indian Express Group


In the 2014 Indian Readership Survey, the Media Research Users Council list The Indian Express in ranking the top ten Indian English dailies by the size of readership, more than 361,000 readers.[2] According to comScore reports, its website was India's third largest English-language news website reaching over 6 million unique visitors a month in India on desktop and laptop computers.[citation needed] In 2015, The Indian Express App won gold for the Best Mobile News Service in South Asia at the World Association of Newspapers' Asian Digital Media Awards.


Source | Link:


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • ...... some days you pick the strawberries ...... ...... some days the strawberries pick you ....
    • there really shouldn't be, especially if you read the whole sentence I wrote. Here, I'll save you the time from searching for it: I find jw's foolish because they follow the ideas of men, which changes to suit those in the power tower.  lol,   we......lol
    • In my “practical wisdom” mode, not my “world is going to hell in a handbasket” mode, I start my door-to-door presentation with an invitation to consider a practical verse like Matthew 6:25. “Anxiety is a huge concern today. We read about it. We experience it. I want to read you a scripture on that theme, you tell me what you think, and I am out of here. Good idea?” You can throw in a factoid or two from somewhere, like something here from the New York Times, but I usually pass. You are looking for people with whom the idea resonates, and if it doesn’t, the New York Times will not convince them that it should.  An affirmative answer to my offer will earn the householder the reading of Matthew 6:25. “On this account I [Jesus] say to you: Stop being anxious about your lives as to what you will eat or what you will drink, or about your bodies as to what you will wear. Does not life mean more than food and the body than clothing?” “That’s all I wanted to do,” I will say, “to get this notion on the table—that anxiety is something that you might hope to just “stop it.” He doesn’t say, don’t start being anxious. He assumes his listeners already are. He says ‘Stop it.’  The next move is the householder’s, and I tell him that he doesn’t have to make one. “If the subject piques interest, if you have views if you.....” and so forth. If he doesn’t (and even if he does), I will leave a tract—any of them will do—and call attention to the jw.org website and what is to be found there. If they do, then conversation might go a hundred different ways. Even so, I do not press every moment to stay. Rather, I offer every moment to leave. Even some lengthy conversations I have cut them sort, to the householder’s  protest. “Yes, you say it now,” I observe, “but after I go you will say, “Man! I wanted to get some stuff done today, and then this Bible guy showed up!” Maybe I have grown sensitive to all the concerns of those who cry over “manipulation,” and so I am determined to not even give the appearance of going there. Of course, the extremists among these ones are babies to whom introducing any idea not mainstream is “manipulation,”—they decry all “brainwashing” except for the brainwashing that is theirs—and there is not much one can do about that, but I try not to attract the charge like a magnet. I can hear Anthony Morris giving the talk now at the 2016 Regional Convention in Atlanta. I wasn’t there—I was at another convention—but the talk was streamed. “‘Stop it!’ Jesus says. Just ‘stop it!’ as though addressing a child—and that was the idea that he went on to develop, that it was a controllable emotion. It was a meaningful talk for me. Anxiety had proven to be a weakness for me —it afflicts some in the family—and when I was hit with a perfect storm of calamities, I did not blame humans like JTR does. I did worse and blamed God.  Believe me, I envy those brothers—I have met a lot of them—who say: “I’ve never worried a day in my life!” To be sure, that envy is tempered by the fact that some of these characters caused plenty of others to worry, and even when it was not so, they had other weaknesses to compensate or even more than compensate. We are all “pieces of work” in one way or another. I also know quite a few who, by choice, live very close to the wire. They have structured their lives that way. It is deliberate. They have determined to “make use of the world, but not use it to the full.” (1 Corinthians 7:31) They have decided to go light as to material things. The ideal among Jehovah’s Witnesses—which some have attained and some have not—is to acquire a skill that pays well, and then do as little of it as possible so as to have as large a share as possible in the kingdom proclamation work. I am not one of those people, either, but I sort of envy them, as the modern manifestation of Paul, who knew “how to be low on provisions and how to have an abundance. In everything and in all circumstances I have learned the secret of both how to be full and how to hunger, both how to have an abundance and how to do without.” - Philippians 4:12  These ones will crinkle a fender on their car and ask God what to do about it, since there’s no money in the budget for the mishap. What is God going to do about it? Time and again persons I know well have reported such things—they take it to God in prayer—and presently the answer presents itself in totally unanticipated ways, sometimes very unlikely ones. They thereafter attribute it to God’s spirit. Am I going to tell them that they are wrong? Why would I do that? How do I know? It is more likely—when you hear such things again and again—that they are right. I do what Mary did, with regard to different experiences: “Mary began to preserve all these sayings, drawing conclusions in her heart.” (Luke 2:19) Maybe they’ll do me some good someday, the same way they did her. Key is the confidence of 1 John 5:14: “And this is the confidence that we have toward him, that no matter what we ask according to his will, he hears us.” For it to work it must be “according to his will.” It seems that it will be very hard to dictate to someone else just how holy spirit is supposed to work. Almost by definition, you cannot. It is the wind of John 3:8 that you feel but cannot see. It is the angels that the cosmonauts did not see—and so concluded from that experience that there was no God. No, it operates as it operates and is one of those “taste and see” sort of things.  
    • Twyla, Thanks always for the biweekly spiritual food. Enjoy your day and week.
    • I think I didn’t miss a thing. You are either doing something unmentionable or you are making your escape—and not a moment too soon. Besides, I just made that line up myself. If it turns out that movie plagiarized it, they’ve got a major lawsuit on their hands.
    • Does that mean Jesus got his drivers license when he was 31?
  • Popular Now

  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Service Confirmation Terms of Use Privacy Policy Guidelines We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.