Jump to content

Topic Summary

Created

Last Reply

Replies

Views

The Librarian -
JW Insider -
7
336

Top Posters


Recommended Posts


David Splane and Doing the Math

Do the Math

In the September JW Broadcast David Splane gave a talk on the above title. In it he raised the question whether Noah and Abraham knew each other. He claims that doing the math could help you answer that question. He begins by stating that, according to Insight on the Scriptures, we know for a fact the flood occurred in 2370 B.C.E. He lived for 350 years after the flood so that means he died in 2020 B.C.E. Abram entered Canaan in 1943 B.C.E. At the time he is 75 years old. Add 75 to 1943 means Abram was born in 2018 B.C.E. so, doing the math helps us to establish that Abram was born 2 years after Noah died.

In Genesis Chapter 11, it gives a genealogy from Shem all the way down to Abram.

And it says how old each person was when their son was born. It says that Arpachshad was 35 when his son was born, and Shelah was 30 when his son was born. But what David Splane did not take into consideration is that modern translations of the Bible are translated from the Hebrew Masoretic text, which is not the original Hebrew. But rather, a copy of the Hebrew, called the Leningrad Codex, which was produced in the 11th century A.D. But the Greek Septuagint was translated more than 1,000 years before, in 250 B.C., and would not have been translated from the Hebrew on which the Masoretic Text was based. But rather, from an older Hebrew text, which is no longer available. The Samaritan Pentateuch also pre-dates the Masoretic text and would also have referenced an older copy of the Hebrew. The Jewish historian Josephus agrees with both the Septuagint and the Samaritan Pentateuch.

In the Greek Septuagint it says that Arphaxad was 135. And it says that Shelah was 130. The Greek Septuagint has an extra 100 years on those ages in the six generations from Arphaxad down to Serug. Also, the Masoretic text says that Nahor was 29 years old when he fathered Terah Abrams father. The Septuagint says he was 79.

The Greek Septuagint has an extra 100 years on each one of those ages. But it's not just the Greek Septuagint. The Samaritan Pentateuch includes those extra hundred years and so does Flavius Josephus. That means there is an extra 650 years of history between Arpachshad and Serug. Noah lived 350 years after the flood. (Gen.9:28) Arpachshad was born 2 years after the flood. (Gen. 11:10) According to the Septuagint:

Arphaxad 135 years until Shelah

Shelah 130 years until Eber

Eber 134 years until Phalek

Phalek 130 years until Ragau

Ragau 132 years until Serouch

Serouch 130 years until Nachor

Nachor 79 years until Thara

Thara 27 years until Abram

Adding the above gives us a total of 897 years between Arphaxad and Abram. Adding two years between Arphaxad and the flood gives us 899 years. Subtracting 350 years of Noah’s life after the flood means Noah died, not two years according to Splane, but 549 years before Abram was born. This is the result if you “do the math” based on the Septuagint.

Interestingly, accepting these figures calls into question another statement of David Splane. In a previous broadcast he commented on the age of the Sphinx as dated to 2,550 B.C.E. by historians being wrong because it conflicted with the Bible account of the flood. But that’s only if you accept the Masoretic text figures as being correct.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/7/2019 at 9:43 PM, Jack Ryan said:

The Greek Septuagint has an extra 100 years on each one of those ages.

Those who have too much invested into the MT will often word this as 'for some reason the LXX translators decided to change the age at which the various patriarchs begat sons and their ages at their death.' Of course, this begs the question about whether the LXX was original and it was the Masoretes who decided to change the ages. But it wasn't the fault of the Masoretes, as this question had already been noticed by Eusebius (4th century, 260-340 CE) and others before the Masoretes came on the scene.

A good, well-documented article on this is here:

    Hello guest!

Note that it says:

  • Most ancient Christian scholars argued for the originality of the LXX’s primeval chronology. This strong consensus lasted for over 14 centuries until the Reformation, when the MT supplanted the primacy of the LXX in the western church.

Josephus uses the LXX, and the writers of the Christian Greek Scriptures (NT) nearly always quoted from the LXX, so it would be natural that Christian scholars would defend the LXX.

----edited to add----

For those wondering what the DSS would say here, we have only this answer from another good article:

A2: No fragments or manuscripts of Genesis 5 and 11 with the numbers were found in the Dead Sea caves, so there is no evidence from those discoveries to directly help us. One tiny fragment was found in Cave 4 at Qumran. Text from Gen 4 is on the right side of the fragment, on the far left, one word from Genesis 5:13 or 14 appears, "Kenan."

The best external evidence we have that corroborates the longer chronology found in the LXX are from four sources that pre-date the second century AD: Demetrius (Greek, third century BC), Eupolemus (Hebrew/Greek, second century BC), Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum (LAB, Hebrew-based, first century AD), and Josephus (Hebrew-based, first century AD).

The article is here:

    Hello guest!

The conclusion of that article was that it was 2nd century rabbis, 300 years AFTER the LXX, and which therefore had the influence on the later MT:

There are two main hypotheses that have been presented in the academic literature: it was either the Alexandrian Jews who translated the LXX Pentateuch in Egypt in 281 BC (the LXX “inflation” hypothesis), or the second century AD rabbis in Israel. We encourage you to read

    Hello guest!
and
    Hello guest!
to understand why it cannot be the Alexandrian translators, and why the rabbis had strong motive, unique means, and rare opportunity to deliberately reduce the primeval chronology on the order of 1250 years. We submit that only the rabbis could have gotten away with such an egregious and large-scale manipulation of the biblical texts in the proto-MT textual tradition. We will also examine the antediluvian chronology in the Book of Jubilees, its close affinities with Genesis 5 in the Samaritan Pentateuch, and then propose how (many of) the figures in Genesis 5 SP originated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Similar Content

    • By The Librarian
      The Holy Bible > The King James Bible > Genesis > Exodus
      <----- Genesis 10               Genesis 12 ----->
       
      And the whole earth was of one language, and of one speech.
      2 And it came to pass, as they journeyed from the east, that they found a plain in the land of Shinar; and they dwelt there.
      3 And they said one to another, Go to, let us make brick, and burn them thoroughly. And they had brick for stone, and slime had they for morter.
      4 And they said, Go to, let us build us a city and a tower, whose top may reach unto heaven; and let us make us a name, lest we be scattered abroad upon the face of the whole earth.
      5 And the Lord came down to see the city and the tower, which the children of men builded.
      6 And the Lord said, Behold, the people is one, and they have all one language; and this they begin to do: and now nothing will be restrained from them, which they have imagined to do.
      7 Go to, let us go down, and there confound their language, that they may not understand one another's speech.
      8 So the Lord scattered them abroad from thence upon the face of all the earth: and they left off to build the city.
      9 Therefore is the name of it called Babel; because the Lord did there confound the language of all the earth: and from thence did the Lord scatter them abroad upon the face of all the earth.
      10 These are the generations of Shem: Shem was an hundred years old, and begat Arphaxad two years after the flood:
      11 And Shem lived after he begat Arphaxad five hundred years, and begat sons and daughters.
      12 And Arphaxad lived five and thirty years, and begat Salah:
      13 And Arphaxad lived after he begat Salah four hundred and three years, and begat sons and daughters.
      14 And Salah lived thirty years, and begat Eber:
      15 And Salah lived after he begat Eber four hundred and three years, and begat sons and daughters.
      16 And Eber lived four and thirty years, and begat Peleg:
      17 And Eber lived after he begat Peleg four hundred and thirty years, and begat sons and daughters.
      18 And Peleg lived thirty years, and begat Reu:
      19 And Peleg lived after he begat Reu two hundred and nine years, and begat sons and daughters.
      20 And Reu lived two and thirty years, and begat Serug:
      21 And Reu lived after he begat Serug two hundred and seven years, and begat sons and daughters.
      22 And Serug lived thirty years, and begat Nahor:
      23 And Serug lived after he begat Nahor two hundred years, and begat sons and daughters.
      24 And Nahor lived nine and twenty years, and begat Terah:
      25 And Nahor lived after he begat Terah an hundred and nineteen years, and begat sons and daughters.
      26 And Terah lived seventy years, and begat Abram, Nahor, and Haran.
      27 Now these are the generations of Terah: Terah begat Abram, Nahor, and Haran; and Haran begat Lot.
      28 And Haran died before his father Terah in the land of his nativity, in Ur of the Chaldees.
      29 And Abram and Nahor took them wives: the name of Abram's wife was Sarai; and the name of Nahor's wife, Milcah, the daughter of Haran, the father of Milcah, and the father of Iscah.
      30 But Sarai was barren; she had no child.
      31 And Terah took Abram his son, and Lot the son of Haran his son's son, and Sarai his daughter in law, his son Abram's wife; and they went forth with them from Ur of the Chaldees, to go into the land of Canaan; and they came unto Haran, and dwelt there.
      32 And the days of Terah were two hundred and five years: and Terah died in Haran.
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.
    • By Jack Ryan
      2019 BRD Newsletter
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.   2019 BRD Visitor Center Newsletter Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.   2019--S-147-19-05-E Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • Guest Indiana
      By Guest Indiana
    • By James Thomas Rook Jr.
      wow!
      It's been NINE years since the first "Shepherd the Flock Of God" Elder's handbook came out, that was so top secret that non-elders were forbidden to read it, and sisters were not even allowed  to touch it, and to this day, most Jehovah's Witnesses are not aware that the book even exists.  At the same time copies were given to the Finnish Department of Justice, and the Department of Education, and the Australian Royal Commission on Child Abuse.
      Here it is 2019, and the latest 2019 version is out, available all over the Internet in PDF format, but I have not had a chance to read it yet.    
      I still do not know what all the top secret hub-bub was about .... I read the 2010 version and the subsequent updates, and found it a fine publication that ALL Jehovah's Witnesses would benefit from reading.
      I did not mention I knew of the 2010 version's existence until they started giving out copies to lots of government officials, my reasoning being that the Society had thereby "declassified" it.
      Does anybody know if the Society has given the OK for the general Brotherhood to read this book, by which we are governed?
      Can any Brother or Sister at the Kingdom Hall request, and get a copy?
      I will ask at my Weekend Meeting, in two days, and let you know what I have found out.
    • By Jack Ryan
      Here some points I noted not sure if these r different from the previous edition:
      medical marijuana is a personal choice
      Any allegations of child sexual abuse r to b given to the legal department to tell the elders how to proceed.
      Also specific instructions to not make abused persons face their accuser
      The elders should all b made aware of any sexual predators and if they move the new congregation elders should b made aware including parents of children in the congregation. This is only done if the legal department says to.
      Victims of abuse or their parents r to b advised that they can go to the police and r not to b discouraged from doing so.
      Masturbation is not pornia and is not really covered. Not sure if this is new and the org is backing away from discussing it.
      Probing sexual questions r to b avoided during a judicial committee
      Sexual offenders r not to receive any major privileges in the congregation, possibly minor ones such as handling mics after an extended time has passed.
      The elders r to clearly tell people that they r being invited to a judicial committee and what the meeting is about up front.
      Things they r still clinging to:
      Still sticking to the two witnesses rule for child abuse
      it says that attempted suicide victims may b subject to a judicial committee ( someone that has mental illness should not b subject to more trauma I find this to b so disgusting)
      Of course all the other ridiculous invasive restrictions we all have experienced
      Highlights from the book above (2019 links added)
      The three year rule is re-iterated without specific mention of "three"
      An elder or MS will be removed if he allows his adult DA'd child to move into family home
      An elder can be removed for filing for bankruptcy
      The language around the definition of rape is better - no more references to the woman having to scream
      The stayover rule is still there. If you stay in the house of a member of the opposite sex, and two people know about it, it's a judicial matter.
      "Abhorrent" forms of porn are now a DF offense. Gay, Lez, child, violent, bestial.
      Gluttony is now listed as a DF offense. Not sure if it was there before
      They have narrowed the definition of apostasy: " Deliberately Spreading Teachings Contrary to Bible Truth " the end of that sentence used to read "as taught by Jehovah's Witnesses"
      I think this the first time they explicitly stated that marking talks can be given based on misconduct from unbaptized minors
      There's a whole new section on CSA. It seems like an improvement overall and includes the child no longer having to confront her rapist in most cases, but it still doesn't have the promised female representation from Jackson's promise to the Australian court.
      Willingly taking blood remains an automatic disassociation offence.
      Reinstatement is "several months, a year or even longer"
      Ownership of kingdom halls. They make clear that regardless of what it says on the title, a congregation does not OWN their own kingdom hall.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content. email - all correspondance between elders is now via the elders private account on Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content. . I guess they want to make sure they know EVERYTHING Congregation file: Still they say the best place to keep it is at the KH. Therefore, paper records of all judicial matters should be in those files. ALL CSA RECORDS HAVE "DO NOT DESTROY" WRITTEN ON THEM
      Here's the entire section on legal action as a result of judicial action. I think it's worth noting that it demonstrates that they will leave you alone if you write a legal letter:
       
      IF THE ACCUSED THREATENS LEGAL ACTION 18. If the accused threatens legal action against the elders, the elders should suspend proceedings and promptly telephone the Legal Department. 19. If a member ofthe media or an attorney representing the accused contacts the elders, they should not give any information about PREPARING FOR JUDICIAL HEARINGS CHAPTER 15 “SHEPHERD THE FLOCK OF GOD” the case or verify that there is a judicial committee. Rather, they should give the following explanation: “The spiritual and physical welfare of Jehovah’s Witnesses is of paramount concern to the elders, who willingly provide spiritual assistance to congregation members. The elders extend this spiritual assistance confidentially. This makes it easier for those who seek the elders’ help to do so without worrying that what they say to the elders will be divulged later. Consequently, we do not comment on whether elders are currently or have formerly met to assist any member of the congregation.” If there is a need to do so, the elders may obtain the inquirer’s name and phone number and inform him that their attorney will contact him. The elders should then promptly telephone the Legal Department. 20. Ifthe authorities request confidential congregation records or ask that elders give testimony regarding confidential congregation matters, the elders should promptly telephone the Legal Department.
       
      This seems like a big change below as it codifies what we have all been hearing about ownership of KH's:
       
      OWNERSHIP 2. A Kingdom Hall is dedicated to the worship of Jehovah. Whether the property title, or deed, is held in the name of a local corporation or by means of a trustee arrangement or it is held in the name of a legal entity managed by the branch office, no congregation should conclude that it “owns” the Kingdom Hall. However, it is the responsibility of the congregations using the property to care for it and see that it is used in harmony with Kingdom interests. 3. As many as three or four congregations may be assigned by the branch office to use the same Kingdom Hall auditorium in order to make full use of the facility and to keep expenses to a minimum. The branch office will generally correspond with only one of the congregations using the facility regarding legal, property, and related matters. Usually, this contact congregation holds the documents related to the Kingdom Hall and the property on which it is located. This is for practical reasons only and does not provide a basis for the contact congregation to make unilateral
    • By Jack Ryan
      Christian Congregation of Jehovah’s Witnesses The Ridgeway, London, NW7 1RN Telephone: 020 8906 2211
      SDI December 31, 2018
      TO ALL FIELD SERVICE GROUP OVERSEERS
      Re: Auxiliary Pioneering in March 2019
      Dear Brothers:
      We are aiming for an all-time peak in auxiliary pioneers during March 2019, which will be announced to the congregation in the Announcements and Reminders (S-147) form for January 2019. How can you and your fellow elders assist?
      During January, arrange to meet with your group. (Where a group is cared for by a ministerial servant, the body of elders should assign an elder to meet with the group servant and the group.) In the meeting, kindly and tactfully build enthusiasm for this campaign. Share practical suggestions to help the publishers plan ahead.
      This March campaign offers you an excellent opportunity to give even greater attention to your assignment. (ks10 chap. 2 pars. 22, 23) Warmly commend the brothers for the efforts they make to increase their share in the ministry.
      Thank you very much for giving this matter your prompt attention. We are confident that, through your loving efforts and Jehovah’s blessing, this initiative will increase praise to his name. Please accept our warm brotherly affection and greetings.
      Your brothers,
      😄 All elders
      Circuit overseers
       
        Both BOE's are in a zipped folder.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content. Atlantis!"
    • By The Librarian
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      This issue contains the study articles for May 6 to June 2, 2019

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      Consider some of the challenges that face us and what it will take to make this world a safe and secure place to live.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      This issue contains the study articles for April 8 to May 5, 2019

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      The Bible book of Ezekiel contains many prophecies that focus on the restoration of pure worship. How do these prophecies involve us?

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.  
       

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.

      CHAPTERS VIDEO DOWNLOAD LINKS


      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.
      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.

      Your browser does not support the HTML5 video tag.
    • By John Houston
      Was curious if there would be a posting of the upcoming season of assembly talks. It would benefit us who may be unable to go, for personal study and research. Any answer would suffice. Thanks for your time.
    • By The Librarian
      This publication is designed to help sharpen your skills in public reading and in the arts of speaking and teaching.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      What you do every day can make God’s heart rejoice.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      This issue contains the study articles for March 4 to April 7, 2019

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
    • By The Librarian
      General instructions for how the midweek meeting should proceed.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in (it's free) to view the hidden content.
  • Forum Statistics

    60,861
    Total Topics
    110,870
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    16,344
    Total Members
    1,592
    Most Online
    Dafniter
    Newest Member
    Dafniter
    Joined




×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Service Confirmation Terms of Use Privacy Policy Guidelines We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.